Wednesday, June 19, 2013

The Consequence of a Unanimous Decision


By Lorry Blath

Most scientists had disregarded Mary-Claire King’s 16 years of work with genetics as impracticable for use in the clinic. Her findings in the early 1990’s eventually proved them mistaken. The discovery of a mutation on chromosome 17, now known as “the BRCA gene”, revolutionized how researchers approach genetic information in developing new strategies for treatment and prevention of diseases.
Everyone has BRCA genes. BRCA 1 and 2’s function is to repair cell damage and keep the breast growing normally. When these genes mutate in one generation, all subsequent generations may, but not always, inherit an increased risk to develop breast, ovarian, and prostate cancers. Scientists know there are more than these two mutated genes, which carry the tendency toward breast cancer, but BRCAs are the most common, accounting for up to 10% of all breast cancers.
Myriad Genetics, founded by researchers, developed tests for eight different genetic diseases. In the case of BRCA1 and 2, Myriad applied for and received a patent on the BRCA genes. This patent precluded any other team from developing any similar or improved test for patients. In a new era among researchers of collaboration, information sharing, and encouragement, this monopoly seemed opportunist, making half a billion dollars a year for Myriad, at up to $3,500 per test.

The recent Supreme Court ruling on this issue stated that no one can “own” natural or genetic materials. They can patent a test, but not the human gene. This will not only lower the cost of this particular test, but will also encourage more collaboration among scientists. This is a victory for all kinds of cancer and will open the floodgates on ideas for further discoveries.

No comments:

Post a Comment